4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

Número de respuestas: 24

Teaching and learning are two related but different concepts.  We can be in a classroom (real or virtual, formal or informal) where concepts are taught...but we don't learn.  And other times we can be in a situation where lessons are taught in a way that we not only learn, but are inspired to learn more, teach others or change our practice.

Take a few minutes to reflect on activities that you have experienced as a participant in or outside of the classroom.  Your situation may have been in an informal or a formal setting.  What made the experience memorable for you?  Describe why you think you learned from it, what were the activities that worked why did they work?

(Post a response and respond to two colleagues...)

En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Jeremy Kraus -
I want to write more on the other side of this as I have had more questions than answers lately, but I won't. I completed the Advancing Environmental Education Practices course led by Dr. Marianne Krasny and it was all great experiences that connected students in depth to global contemporary environmental ed topics and issues. The whole course validated things I have been doing in extension work and provided me guidance on areas I have been struggling. There were a bunch of people in the course, and it was difficult for everyone to have time to talk, but outside the active learning time students were able to be heard through email and other lines of communication.
En respuesta a Jeremy Kraus

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Daniela Vergara -
That sounds like a really meaningful course experience, especially because it both validated what you are already doing in Extension and gave you guidance in areas that still feel unresolved. I relate to that balance of having more questions than answers, because in online teaching I often think about how to move students from simply receiving information to actively applying, questioning, and reflecting on it.

I also appreciate what you said about people being heard outside the main active learning time. That feels important, especially in virtual or large-group settings where not everyone can fully participate in the moment.

What was one idea or practice from the course that you think you will carry most directly into your Extension work?
En respuesta a Jeremy Kraus

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Sarah Bentley Garfinkel -
I agree, the active learning time outside of the class sounds valuable and could be especially so in virtual learning environments. Depending on the program and participants, I wonder about various platforms - when is email most appropriate, or text, or Google Classroom, or one of the myriad other options? Determining what may be most effective and convenient for learning in various settings - for both facilitators and participants - is something I plan to consider moving forward.
En respuesta a Jeremy Kraus

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Heather Kase -
I also find it so valuable when participants can communicate with each other on their thoughts, interpretations, and experiences with the material! Some of the best learning can come from peer-to-peer interactions
En respuesta a Heather Kase

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Eric Antrim -
That is well said, many of my favorite learning and teaching experiences were from peer-peer interactions that go in depth or even of topic. Looking back, many of my favorite memories from school were when instructors would start conversations to see where they would lead instead of just speaking at the audience for the entire class.
En respuesta a Jeremy Kraus

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Raevyn Saunders -
I found your experience interesting because it highlights a challenge on both ends of the spectrum. In a large group, it can be difficult to make sure everyone has the opportunity to contribute and feel heard. On the other hand, I have found that in smaller groups you can sometimes have the opposite problem, where no one wants to be the first person to speak or engage in the activity.

I think this is where facilitation becomes so important. Creating an environment where participants feel comfortable sharing their thoughts can make a big difference in the level of engagement. Sometimes all it takes is a few guiding questions, small group discussions, or an activity that gets people talking before they feel comfortable contributing to the larger group.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Daniela Vergara -
As an online instructor, I think a lot about the difference between teaching and learning. I teach cannabis science and biochemistry courses virtually, where students may never be in the same physical room, so the activities must be intentional, applied, and engaging.

The experiences I learn from most are the ones where I am asked to actively use the information instead of only receiving it. For example, when a scientific concept is connected to a real-world problem, such as interpreting cannabis testing results, evaluating product claims, or understanding how cannabinoids and terpenes relate to plant biology and human use, the material becomes memorable because it has purpose.

This is also why I have been developing assignments that incorporate AI thoughtfully. Students can use AI to explain biochemical pathways, evaluate cannabis-related claims, or improve scientific communication, but they must also check accuracy, compare outputs with reliable sources, and reflect on limitations. That process works because students are not just memorizing content. They are practicing how to think, question, verify, and communicate.

For me, meaningful learning happens when students leave with skills they can apply beyond the course.
En respuesta a Daniela Vergara

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Sarah Bentley Garfinkel -
Your takeaway about meaningful learning is so important. It reminds me to develop outcomes for all sessions (as feasible) to ensure that the content leads to a skill(s) that can be applied in each and all of the participants' lives.
En respuesta a Daniela Vergara

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Heather Kase -
I so agree when things have a purpose, or students understand the reasoning behind why a leads to b, it is much more meaningful than "well its just this way because it is".
En respuesta a Daniela Vergara

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Amanda Cappadona -
I'm also a learner who finds "case study"-type examples the most helpful. I need to apply the education in order to fully internalize it. However, when I study, I find listening to recordings the most helpful. It's something I found bled into my work as a graduate adjunct lecturer. I ALWAYS record my lectures, because I remember recording lectures and having to export them to be able to listen to them on my iphone in school. Many of my projects are also based in real-life public health practices.
En respuesta a Daniela Vergara

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por adam Bullock -
Daniela,
I agree! your last statement has me reflecting in my experience with SNAP-ed; "meaningful learning happens when students leave with skills they can apply beyond the course."

Oftentimes in SNAP-Ed, and I imagine in may other spaces, I see the inexperienced instructor, or simply those of us who at times do not consider our audience, offer meaningful, yet unattainable skills. For example, teaching how to use various cooking equipment, although many in attendance cannot afford the equipment. Or, teaching how to perform an exercise, while the performing it is unreasonable or unsafe for the participant at home. I think attainability and relevance are definite considerations for creating a learner centered environment when aiming for meaningful and effective learning.
En respuesta a Daniela Vergara

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Jane Rothschild -
This is such a good observation about what kinds of questions and activites really encourage learned espcialy when so many things can be looked up. i love the real-world problem solving focuse of what you described. In our Seed to Supper class, we encourge the faciltators to do that as well. Such as asking particpants to bring their own soil samples in when they do the soil testing/ texture lesson. It makes the ingormation click so much better.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Sarah Bentley Garfinkel -
I had to think through this question for a bit! I don't deliver programs directly to participants but do provide trainings to referring partners (healthcare providers who refer to FVRx for example) and sometimes internally with and for our team, specifically regarding systems change strategies.

In trying to identify a similar model that was a memorable learning experience, I landed on a train the teacher session for a Montessori-style classroom program for young children (unrelated to CCE/paid work). In this case, for part of the session trainees were in the role of students and the trainer served as the teacher. Because the trainer/teacher was so passionate about the educational approach and content we were fully engaged. The teacher/trainer also allowed sufficient time to debrief the experience, which allowed for rich discussion and shared ahas among the full group.

This is a valuable reminder that ensuring time for debrief and discussion can be a critical piece of the learning puzzle. I am working to edit myself - talk less and allow more open space for conversation, questioning, grappling, and even finding the wow in the learning experience.
En respuesta a Sarah Bentley Garfinkel

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Eric Antrim -
That is awesome and rings true. Debriefing and discussion can be just as valuable as the exercise and help drive home the overall message. I also need to focus on editing myself and improve my listening skills to get the most out of the conversation and questioning to maximize the "wow".
En respuesta a Sarah Bentley Garfinkel

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por adam Bullock -
Sarah,
I do also appreciate those debriefing sessions and am working on talking less and allowing more open space for conversation - particularly as a Direct Ed Instructor.
Thankfully the 8-week Stay Strong Stay Healthy Curriculum allows for plenty of time to explain skills and knowledge, and then some for story sharing. the duration of the program is fruitful for garnering stronger relationships, which leads to deeper conversations, questions, and wisdom from participants. I also plan for time before and after program to connect. I don't have the same approach to PSE change, as it is harder and seems to take much longer to develop those deep relationships with new partners. I wish to create more learning and connection between partners in coalitions and community-based service workgroups.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Eric Antrim -
I recently had a chance to participate in setting up a relatively complex field trial and was reminded how important preparation is to successfully execute a goal, in this a case a corn silage evaluation. I wasn’t sure what to expect and showed up to a bare field (blank canvas). We measured and remeasured the plot before splitting it up into blocks, where the varieties were placed and replicated three times. Luckily, the large and tedious task of separating the seed into individual packets and placing them in the order they were to be planted had already been completed. The planter was automated with GPS, but the loading of the seed was manual, and cued by the sound of the planter refilling the next round of seed and a beep that indicated the seed had been drilled and was approaching the next block. There were a few hiccups at first, but I learned about the equipment and how to dial it in. More importantly it reinforced how proper preparation improves effectiveness and efficiency. Getting the chance to collaborate with experienced researchers was memorable and inspiring.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Heather Kase -
I think the programs where I learn and felt inspired to learn more are when you may be taught in a classroom, but then there's a hands on aspect to it. I feel as thought putting the material learned in the program to physical use makes me want to learn more as to why something is done, how it could it be done differently, and how other people are doing it. I found I got this experience from working and going to grad school online. My MPHM work aligned with my job completely, so I was able to listen to lectures and then apply what I learned to the field and share it with my growers. This helped solidify concepts in my mind because I could see how they were used in real life. I think that's important and it's why I love doing in-person programs, such as blueberry pruning workshops. Also, the host farm gets pruning done by volunteers so its a win-win.
En respuesta a Heather Kase

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Jeremy Kraus -
Being a very kinesthetic learners myself, I agree 100% with adding or making learning experiences hands-on! Balancing different delivery strategies geared toward the program goals for learners and understanding different learning styles and capabilities of your audience is incredibly important these days.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Amanda Cappadona -
Over the past few years, I have participated in many educational opportunities surrounding trauma-informed nutrition education and mental health. These have been likely the most impactful to me, especially when teaching tactics that are no longer considered "best practices" have evidence to back up potential harm. I'm someone who responds strongly to evidence and not-so-strongly to much else, and being shown literature and examples of why I should tweak my teaching methods was the more impactful to me. I also found multi-media use to be most engaging, as well as some audience participation (though this can be a challenge at times)!
En respuesta a Amanda Cappadona

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Jane Rothschild -
This is interesting because it made me think about how people are influced by diffent stategies. Like for you, the evidence goes a long way, for some they are put off by that. Some prefer story telling, or event game-style simulations to allow them to find their own way tot he conculusion you are teaching about. I have been thinking about how to use some of the harder to practice methods for those that arn't easily conviced with facts. I like your multimedia example alot. I feel like it could be a good way to show rather than tell the audience new information.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por adam Bullock -
I have a history of needing to be right and wanting to be in positions of influence and power. I also love teaching and explaining nuances. I have learned the difference between teaching and facilitation and am practicing the art of creating learning environments that welcome diverse knowledge and lived experiences to meet the needs of those in participation. Creating great learning environments is a skill. I believe that skill is sharpened when we hold a balance of confidence, humility, and curiosity. When we have the experience and confidence we can improvise an agenda, hold our knowledge beside that of which participants share, ask questions, make space for all participants to share in one way or another, and leave time for conversation and exploration. Oftentimes we, as participants, invest in a program/ class because of our interpretation of it, and many times the actual objectives do not meet our preconceived expectations. If the facilitator has the flexibility to pivot, to make their points while leaving time for participants to share their expertise and wonders, by large everyone in the room has greater potential for learning, including the instructor.
I have been part of some great learning environments where the information by students was heard, valued for being a perspective, affirming any fact and experience, by the instructor, while they shared facts, reasoning, their experience, and their curiosities on the topic. I appreciated these experiences so much, fostered by my professors at Brockport, and from my colleagues in Organizational Sustainability.
En respuesta a adam Bullock

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Raevyn Saunders -
I like your point about being flexible and willing to pivot. Even with the best lesson plan, not every learner comes in with the same experiences, confidence level, or learning style. Taking the time to recognize when someone needs a different approach can make a huge difference in their success.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Jane Rothschild -
It is nice to have a prompt to reflect on my experiences as a participant since I have been doing so much facilitation reflection, I havent though much on my own participant learning experiences in a while. Which is ironic because we ask this exact same question when we train Seed to Supper Educators to help them remember what it is like to be a student to help them become better teachers.

I recently got to be a participant in a way, as my supervisor for my CCE Tompkins job taught me to use our wood work tools so that I could be equipped to lead the Compost Bin build we just completed with the help of volunteers and students. I really appreciated the way he taught in a calm, patient, and very respectful way which totally had not been my experience in past jobs where men "taught" me to use tools in often belittling and condescending stressful ways. The impatient, rude, and rushed, perfectionist attitude of past teachers had squashed my confidence and made me avoid that type of work for years. This recent work experience reminded me that is so powerful to be taught in a way that is calm, hands-on, and patient and had the goal of giving me a skill and building my confidence. Thanks to my CCE suporvisor's skill at teaching, I actually was able to learn enough to guide volunteers in something I had for so long been really fearful of. So that goes to show teaching in a way that respects both people's fear, and ability can help them learn much better than assuming they can't do it, or rushing them for efficiency's sake by just stepping in and taking over.
En respuesta a Primera publicación

Re: 4. DISCUSS: Teaching and Learning...

por Raevyn Saunders -
In my graduate program I found case studies to be a way to apply knowledge and get a further understanding of the topics we have learned. While lectures helped provide the background information, I learned the most when I had the opportunity to apply concepts to actual situations and discuss them with others.

I think those experiences were effective because they were interactive and relevant. Instead of just listening to information, I was actively involved in the learning process.

As I develop my Ag Leases 101 program, I hope to incorporate a similar approach by using real examples and discussion opportunities. Since many participants will have their own experiences with leasing land, I think there is a lot of value in creating opportunities for them to learn from both the content and each other.